« 52 Authors: Week 43 - Madison Jones | Main | Chris Rea: You Must Be Evil »

10/29/2015

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

I always think that if I lived next to a body of water like that that I could never be miserable, but, of course, I'm probably wrong.

AMDG

Yes, you are. :-) But it does have restorative properties.

Speaking of Broadchurch, and the previous discussion: I disagree with Grumpy about the effect of Charlotte Rampling's presence. Or rather it didn't have the effect on me--I can see how it would on someone who had the image of her younger sexy self firmly fixed in mind. But I don't, so I just see her as "handsome older woman." I thought she did a great job btw.

That's right. I forgot you have experience of misery in the presence of a large body of water.

AMDG

I thought that BC1 had a definite subtext of faith, whereas BC2 did not.

I think it's rather interesting that Broadchurch and Gracepoint both have those churchy-sounding names, and then the French version is Malaterra.

AMDG

It's been quite a while now since I watched series 2, but I remember that I found the courtroom scenes unbelievable. And there were too many subplots. But because the acting was first-rate, I stayed with it all the way through.

Valid criticisms. It's definitely a somewhat jury-rigged (ha) plot, but those things really didn't affect my enjoyment of it.

And it's true that there wasn't as much of faith in it, but it did have Paul intervening to bring some reasonable degree of both mercy and justice out of it at the end. I didn't find that entirely convincing, but appreciated the effort, so to speak.

I see Gracepoint is on Netflix now, which I don't think it was last time I looked. Guess I'll give it a try. I know y'all said it wasn't as good.

It was to soon after seeing Broadchurch to adjust to the familiar characters saying the same stuff and looking so different, along with characters that had changed a lot. And the acting wasn't as good.


AMDG

They have the Booker prize to a gay Carribean author. Its beyond parody.

To anyone who knows her work, which includes the director, the writers and the other actors, 'Rampling' means slightly perverse sex in thevsame way that Wayne means Western and Clinton means Dirty Harry

I watched both series based on Mac discussing them here and thought they were both excellent. I liked series 2 more than series 1 and maybe that was just my state of mind while watching? Who knows. I did think Charlotte Rampling was very good, along with Tennant and Colman especially. All of the subplots they threw in are probably there to ease the writers ability to continue the show!

With hindsight, I did enjoy Broadchurch2 a great deal.

I liked 1 a good bit better than 2, although the latter was still quite good. I thought 1 was almost flawless.

Just finished watching the first seasons of 'The Bridge' (Danish/Swedish) and 'Rectify,' which is a Sundance Channel series. 'The Bridge' is very good, if not quite up there with 'The Killing.' What makes it stand out is the winning performances of the two leads, the female of which plays a cop with something like Asperger's syndrome. Both she and her male counterpart are excellent.

'Rectify' so far is outstanding -- there are only 6 episodes in the first season. They were all very good, but the closer is a stunner.

"All of the subplots they threw in are probably there to ease the writers ability to continue the show!"

Yes, I wondered about that. And I think they could easily go off the rails if they keep trying to extend this basic story.

Haven't seen The Bridge. But have seen the first two seasons of Rectify...I think only the first two...and am not keen on it. It's very good, very well done. But there's something off-putting about it to me. Haven't really tried to articulate it, but it may be in part just the exhaustion of watching all that misery.

For those who haven't seen it or read about it, Rectify is about a guy freed from death row after 19 years on the basis of DNA evidence (or rather lack thereof, I guess). It's about what's happened to him, to his family, to the small Georgia town where it all takes place, as a result first of the murder and then of his release. And of course the effect on him of 19 years in prison. Also it's not 100% clear that he didn't actually commit the murder. I would kind of half-recommend it--as I said, it's very well done, but I'm not sure I'll watch any more.

Thanks for the recommendations

"there's something off-putting about it to me. Haven't really tried to articulate it, but it may be in part just the exhaustion of watching all that misery."

I haven't seen the second season yet but I can understand that. To me though, there's just something very compelling about the main character. He's like Michael Shannon's characters in 'Shotgun Stories' and 'Take Shelter' -- hard to take your eyes off him.

I think Grumpy watched the Danish 'Killing.' It's ridiculously good. The American remake is okay, but not great.

I've bought the first episode of Season 1 on Amazon instant. I think I've seen trailers for this one.

Last time I looked the Danish Killing was still not on Netflix. I should check again.

A friend in England found me a sale-priced box set of all 3 seasons on DVD not long ago, but when I originally watched season 1 I got it through the library.

I just finished watching season 2 of The Bridge. Good acting, but I think the Asperger’s thing is not quite right. I couldn’t figure out, for instance, how the young man in love with her could be. She’s so robotic and practically un-housebroken; and does she ever bathe? I also wondered about her zooming about in her speedy little car; she hardly seems aware enough of her surroundings to be able to do that.

"the Asperger’s thing is not quite right."

In something I read about the series the creators said that they never specifically state exactly what her diagnosis is, in order not to pigeonhole her. It's Asperger's-like, but not exactly Asperger's. More like some high-functioning sort of autism.

"I couldn’t figure out, for instance, how the young man in love with her could be."

That's very simple, actually. If he's the type of male that's a "rescuer" he could very easily fall for a woman who's attractive and intelligent, but with major issues.

As for her driving you do get the impression the couple times you're in the car with her that it's a bit of a white-knuckle ride. She's with it enough to avoid accidents, but that's about as far as it goes. She's the opposite of a scatterbrain -- I think she'd approach driving in the same tunnel-vision manner in which she approaches everything else. A friend's son has Asperger's -- he's 17, and remarkably proficient at certain things (drawing, writing, computer stuff) but still has problems tying his shoes, for instance, and his handwriting looks like a third grader's. It's a very strange illness.

I've got season 2 on order and am waiting for it to arrive.

Maclin, what did you watch this on? DVD?

I bought all three seasons of The Killing (in Danish) and watched every night for 40 nights. I was transfixed!

Louise, are you referring to Broadchurch 2? Yes, that was on dvd...I think...pretty sure...

Yes, I meant BC2. Did you hire it or purchase? I'd like to see it, but not sure how best to go about it.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)