Cluny Media, and a Couple of Other Literary Things
06/25/2024
Cluny Media is a publisher whose main line of business is the reprinting of Catholic classics, or classics which are in some way connected to and compatible with the Catholic tradition. And when I say reprinting I don't mean a sloppy scan of an old book run through a print-on-demand process. I mean very high-quality work. Here's how they describe their enterprise:
Our publishing philosophy is simple: A book, from cover to cover, should be an artifact, a work of art. Because our business is primarily to take the old and make it new, this philosophy demands a particular, careful process. Unlike the facsimile “republications” of other, similarly motivated publishers, Cluny editions are restorations. The restorative spirit especially animates the production and design elements of the publishing process.
Their "About Us" page goes into more detail about what they do, and why and how they do it. It's worth reading. And supporting.
Over the past four or five months I've bought several of their books, and can vouch for their quality: Caryl Houselander's Letters, Robert Hugh Benson's Lord of the World, and no less than five of Sigrid Undset's works that aren't gigantic novels set in medieval Norway.
This mini-binge began with my desire to re-read Lord of the World. I had read it ten years ago in one of those free Kindle editions which are not well formatted, which meant that it had two strikes against it before I even started reading: strike one was the fact that it was on the Kindle, as I don't like reading anything substantial on an electronic device anyway. I felt like I'd somehow missed something. The topic--the Antichrist and the Apocalypse--has been on my mind, and I wanted to read an actual on-paper edition this time. I shopped around and was led to the Cluny site, which led to the purchase of that book and then the others.
I can pretty confidently say that you'll be impressed with their list (click here), and pleased with the quality of the books. And I'm going to make one specific recommendation, of a title I was very surprised to see: Evelyn Waugh's Decline and Fall.
I was surprised because I would have assumed it's still under copyright, and that whoever owns the copyright would not readily allow anyone else to publish an edition. It was first published in 1928, so maybe the copyright has expired. In any case it's a very good and very funny novel, my favorite of his comic novels. And isn't that cover great?
I'll mention another title which I was a little surprised, and very pleased, to see: the three-volume A History of the Church by Philip Hughes. I'm not in the market for this set, because I own it, in a Sheed & Ward edition of the 1930s and '40s, and I have a strong attachment to it. Back around 1980, when I was seriously considering leaving the Episcopal Church for Rome, I wanted to read something substantial about the history of the Church. Somehow I decided on this one--I have absolutely no memory now of how that came about--and went to some trouble to get hold of it from an out-of-print books dealer. It did its job, and I proceeded.
It's very well-written, as you would expect of an educated Catholic priest of his time (1895-1967). Contemporary historians would probably consider that it goes way too easy on the Church--"triumphalist," they might say, or worse. There's something to that. But I thought it was very fair to the opponents of the Church, and unsparing of the Church's own failings, though it doesn't dwell on the shocking.
And it ends with Luther. The three volumes were originally to be titled The World In Which the Church Was Founded, The Church and the World It Created, and The Church and the Christian World's Revolt Against It. That basic plan was carried out, but I just noticed, in a footnote to the third volume, that it was intended only as "the first half of this third part." I don't know what the story of that is. But Hughes did later publish A Popular History of the Reformation, also available from Cluny. I have a copy but have never read it.
*
There's a new online poetry magazine: New Verse Review. It's published on Substack, which is very much the thing these days. I recognize several of the names associated with it, especially Sally Thomas, whose book of poems I praised here. I like the fact that the new publication not only favors metrical verse but narrative, and, I assume, longer lyric poems. Modern poetry tends to focus on a single epiphanic moment, and I'm in favor of stretching out a bit. Provided, obviously, that that doesn't mean making a not-very-interesting poem even less so by making it longer.
*
There's a new anthology of Rene Girard's writing: All Desire is A Desire For Being. That's a quote from Girard, and it knocked me out. It's something I've been trying to get at in a poem I've been working on (a longish poem, coincidentally), so I immediately wanted to read the book. I've only read one Girard work, I See Satan Fall Like Lightning, and I don't think that sentence occurs in it. The anthology was assembled and edited by Cynthia Haven, who knew Girard personally, knows his work, and has published a biography of him, Evolution of Desire. Here's an article in Church Life Journal, "We Do Not Come In Peace," which seems to be meant as a sort of introduction to the anthology.
The Haven essay is actually an adaptation of the book's introduction. A friend from England brought it for me when he visited in March and I read it not long after (it came out last summer in the UK).
Glad to see that it's out now in the U.S., and a little earlier than expected. It's a very good intro to Girard, although I must say that some of Haven's choices for what's "essential" struck me as a little odd, as a few of the pieces seem kind of obscure.
Posted by: Rob G | 06/25/2024 at 04:33 PM
I don't have any opinion on that. I did notice that there's already another "best of" sort of collection, so am a little surprised that there's another one. Not too much overlap, one would think/hope.
Posted by: Mac | 06/25/2024 at 06:08 PM
If memory serves the other one came out in the 90's. The new one contains a lot of pieces that are more recent.
Posted by: Rob G | 06/25/2024 at 10:14 PM
I was thinking about reading my first John le Carre novel and know that you are a fan. Any recommendation(s) for a good first read? Perhaps Call for the Dead as it is the first Smiley novel? I've seen the tv and film adaptions of the other Smiley stories and have enjoyed those.
Posted by: CK | 07/04/2024 at 05:50 AM
Without hesitating, I'll say either The Spy Who Came In from the Cold or Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. The first one is a tight, sharp, powerful spy story. The second is much longer and more complex, with greater character development and insight into the workings of the secret world of Cold War espionage.
I read Call for the Dead many years ago and don't remember it well at all. I wouldn't dis-recommend it but it didn't make a big impression. I seem to recall that it was more of a murder mystery than a spy novel, but I could be wrong. It would have the advantage, as you say, of giving you the first picture of Smiley. I just looked at the plot summary on Wikipedia and was a little surprised to find that it really does establish Smiley's basic situation and character. That would be a good foundation for further reading but it *may* not be the best choice from the literary point of view. Now that I think of it, I may read it again.
Smiley appears in Spy Who Came In but if I remember correctly his role is relatively small.
Posted by: Mac | 07/04/2024 at 08:39 AM
Those are probably the two novels Le Carre is most famous for, and they are great. That said, all I have read by him is quite good. Also, the movies of each of those is very good too. The Spy Who Came in from the Cold is Richard Burton (1965) and Tinker Tailor is Gary Oldman as George Smiley and from 2011. I never watched the TTSS miniseries with Alec Guinness, but people seem to love it, and Guinness certainly played Smiley more as he is described in the novels. I just prefer movies to longer format TV stuff.
Posted by: Stu | 07/05/2024 at 07:59 AM
Yes the '65 movie is excellent. Very faithful to the book and very good in itself. The plot of the book is such that it could be fit into a movie. Not so with Tinker Tailor. I didn't see the 2011 movie but I've seen some very negative comments about it from people who like the book and the miniseries, which I think is great--too bad you don't care for the format. There's a second one, Smiley's People, which is also excellent.
Posted by: Mac | 07/05/2024 at 09:36 AM