The Symphony Concert Which I Did Not Attend
02/11/2025
I had planned to go, then decided not to go, then decided to go, then didn't. The reasons wouldn't interest you, but one reason for the shifts was that I wasn't all that enthusiastic about the program. There were two pieces, the first being a Concerto Fantasy for Two Timpanists, by Philip Glass.
What? Or as some online young people say: wut. Without a question mark. I really like that because it's utterly expressionless, as if it can't be bothered with more than the bare minimum of effort needed to communicate a combination of incomprehension and indifference in such a way as to suggest that whatever is being responded to is nonsense. Three letters is the bare minimum for representing the sound; four would be far too much trouble.
And that was pretty close to my immediate reaction to the name of the piece. But Phillip Glass is quite a gifted composer, even if one thinks (or suspects) he has written too much that is too similar to other works. I've enjoyed a good bit of his music over the years--I remember especially a performance of his Second Symphony. And rhythm has always been an important element in his music, insistent but constantly shifting. So the day after the concert which I had missed, I looked for the piece on YouTube rather than Idagio, because I was curious as to how the tympani and timpanists would be positioned, and what the two players would look like in action. (I recall it being spelled with a "y," but the title of the Glass piece uses an "i." I don't know why it names the players and not the instruments--you don't say "concerto for pianist.")
And it turned out to be a very enjoyable and interesting work, well worth thirty minutes of my time, and yours I think. And I'm glad I watched it instead of only listening, because there are a lot more drums involved than I realized, and it's a visual spectacle as well as a musical one. There are several performances on YouTube and the drums seemed to be more prominent in the recording in this one.
I admit that I had moments when I was reminded of a trend among rock bands in the late '60s: the drum solo. Cream's Wheels of Fire album gave over most of an LP side to a fifteen-minute performance of "Toad," most of which was solo drumming, accurately described by the AMG reviewer as "numbing." But the orchestra quickly dispelled that sensation.
The second piece on the program was Prokofiev's Romeo and Juliet. Since it was the only other thing on the program, I assume it was the entire ballet, not a suite taken from it. As far as I can remember I have never heard this work. But my classical music consultant tells me that it's a great work, and sent me a link to this excerpt:
And I'm puzzled, because it seems very familiar. Has it been used in a movie or some other context where I would have heard it, and more than once?
I have definitely heard that, and more than once, but I couldn't tell you where. It does sound like the type of thing that could have been used in a movie.
Posted by: Rob G | 02/12/2025 at 07:19 PM
"Dance of the Knights" has been used in A Clockwork Orange, The Shining and Kill Bill, according to a couple of websites.
I heard it for the first in a cartoon years ago when I was a kid long before I knew what it was. I seem to remember a bunch of giant robots menacingly marching through a downtown. My first thought that it might have been the old "Underdog" cartoon show, but I can't say for certain.
Bob P.
Posted by: Bob Pokoj | 02/13/2025 at 09:12 AM
Thanks for the info. And I haven't seen any of those movies. I could have seen it in a cartoon though I don't remember watching Underdog. .
Now that I think about it, I did see a bit of Kill Bill once. Not more than ten or fifteen minutes, I think. Seems unlikely that even I heard the music then that it would have imprinted to that degree. Puzzling...
Posted by: Mac | 02/13/2025 at 01:49 PM
Of course, to get the full expressionless effect, you have to omit the period:
wut
Posted by: Thaddeus Gotcher | 02/13/2025 at 03:15 PM
Ha! You are quite right. And believe it or not--I wouldn't blame you if you didn't-- I thought of that. My desire to do justice to the word struggled with my horror at leaving off the period at the end of a sentence. The latter won.
Posted by: Mac | 02/13/2025 at 04:25 PM
Thanks for the Glass piece, which I'd never heard of before. Well worth the 30 minutes, and I will listen/watch again. I always love watching the percussion section at a symphony concert, so this was a real treat.
Posted by: Anne-Marie | 02/14/2025 at 08:13 PM
You're welcome. I generally can't see the percussionists, due to a combination of poor eyesight, distance, and their position at the back of the orchestra. It was indeed a lot of fun to watch these two. The piece keeps them hopping.
Posted by: Mac | 02/14/2025 at 09:24 PM
It occurs to me that the piece is probably called "for two timpanists" to make the setup clear. If you say "concerto for tympani" the assumption is one soloist, but you can't say "for two tympani" because there are about fifteen drums involved.
Posted by: Anne-Marie | 02/19/2025 at 01:49 PM
Of course!
Posted by: Mac | 02/19/2025 at 02:31 PM